Hadith No: 6
Ibn al-Athir - Asad al-Ghabah fi Ma'rifat al-Sahabah
Letter Meem - Chapter Meem and Alif - 4654: Malik ibn Nuwayrah
Volume: (5) - Page Number: (48)
[The text is long, so only the relevant excerpt is provided here]
- Malik ibn Nuwayrah ibn Hamzah ibn Shaddad ibn Ubayd ibn Thalabah ibn Yarbuu' al-Tamimi al-Yarbuu'i, brother of Mutammim ibn Nuwayrah
came to the Prophet (peace be upon him and his holy progeny), embraced Islam, and the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him and his holy progeny) appointed him over some of the alms of the Banu Tamim. When the Prophet (peace be upon him and his holy progeny) passed away, the Arabs reneged on their faith, and Sajah appeared, claiming prophethood. He made peace with her, but no apostasy was shown by him, and he remained in al-Bat hah. When Khalid finished with Banu Asad and Ghatfan, he marched to Malik and arrived at al-Bat hah but found no one there, for Malik had dispersed them and instructed them not to gather. When Khalid arrived at al-Bat hah, he sent out his detachments, and they brought Malik ibn Nuwayrah and a few of his people. The detachments disagreed about them, and among them was Abu Qatadah. He was one of those who testified that they prayed together, remained, and worshipped. He imprisoned them one night in the cold and ordered Khalid to announce, "Warm your captives," which in the language of Kinanah means killing. So, they killed them. Khalid heard the commotion and went out to see that they had been killed, then married Khalid's wife. Umar said to Abu Bakr: "The sword of Khalid is in error and he is acting with more than what is appropriate." Abu Bakr replied: "He was interpreting but made a mistake, and I will not scold a sword that Allah unleashed upon the polytheists." He paid the blood money for Malik and Khalid came to Abu Bakr. Umar said to him: "Enemy of Allah, you killed a man who was a Muslim, then you overstepped by marrying his wife. I will stone you!" It is said that when the Muslims surrounded Malik and his companions at night, they took up arms and said, "We are the Muslims." Malik's companions replied, "And we are the Muslims." They said to them, "Put down your weapons and pray." Khalid excused himself for killing him, saying that Malik had said, "I do not think your companion said anything other than this." He replied, "Do you not consider him a companion to you?" and killed him. Mutammim ibn Nuwayrah came to Abu Bakr seeking justice for his brother's blood and for them to be returned their captives. Abu Bakr ordered the return of the captives and paid the blood money for Malik from the public treasury. All of this was mentioned by al-Tabari and other imams and indicates that he did not apostatize, and they mentioned companions who were further removed than this, so their neglect of them is astonishing. There was disagreement about his apostasy, while Umar said to Khalid: "You killed a man who was a Muslim," and Abu Qatadah testified that they prayed and remained together. Abu Bakr ordered the return of the captives and gave Malik's diya from the public treasury. All of this indicates that he was a Muslim ....