Ahle Bayt Repo

عربي

We, the group of vicegerents are not born from the womb

Hadith No: 1
Allamah Majlisi - Bihār al-Anwār
Volume: (51) - Page Number: (25)
- He said: Al-Husayn ibn Hamdan, and one of the trustworthy elders narrated to me from a reliable source among the elders, from Hakimah, the daughter of Muhammad ibn Ali al-Ridha (peace be upon him), who said: She would enter upon Abu Muhammad (peace be upon him) and pray for him that Allah grant him a son. She said: I entered upon him and spoke to him as I usually do and prayed as I usually pray. He said: "O aunt, perhaps the one you are asking Allah to grant me will be born this night," and it was the night of Friday, three nights before the end of Sha'ban in the year 257 AH. "So make your iftar with us." I said: "O my master, from whom will this great child be?" He (peace be upon him) replied: "From Narjis, O aunt." She then said to him, "O my master, there is no one in your household more dear to me than her." I stood up and went to her, and whenever I entered, she would treat me as she always did. I knelt at her feet, kissed them, and prevented her from doing what she used to do. She addressed me with the title of superiority, and I responded to her in kind. She said to me: "May I be sacrificed for you." I replied: "I am yours to sacrifice, and may all the worlds be yours." She denied this, so I said to her: "Do not deny what I have done, for Allah will grant you a son this night, a master in this world and the Hereafter, and he is the awaited relief of the believers." She felt shy, and I observed her, but I saw no sign of pregnancy in her. I said to my master Abu Muhammad (peace be upon him): "I do not see any indication of pregnancy in her." He (peace be upon him) smiled and then said: "We, the progeny of the Prophets, are not carried in wombs, but in sides, and we do not emerge from mothers' bodies; rather, we emerge from the right thigh of our mothers, for we are the light of Allah, which cannot be touched by impurity."....
Reason for the weakness of the narration: Al-Husayn ibn Hamdan al-Khusaybi.

Reference: Behaar al-Anwaar Book 51
Hadith No: 2
Ibn Dawud al-Hilli - Rijal Ibn Dawud
Page number: (240)
140 - Al-Husayn ibn Hamdan al-Khuseibi: with a dotted khah, an unmarked sad, a yeh with two dots underneath, and a single ba, so I saw it written in the handwriting of Abu Ja'far. Some of our companions said: (al-Hadzhayni) with an unmarked ha, a dotted dhad, a yeh with two dots underneath, and an nūn. He died in the month of Rabi' al-Awwal in the year 358. Al-Janbalani, with a rounded jim, a silent nūn, and a single ba, was Abu Abdullah. (Jash) was of corrupt belief.

Reference: Rijaal Ibn Dawood
Hadith No: 3
Muhammad Ali al-Urdubili - Jamia al-Rawat
Volume: (1) - Page Number: (237)
- .... Al-Husayn ibn Hamdan al-Junbalani al-Hasin, Abu Abdullah, narrated from him al-Tal'akkbari [He was not corrupt in doctrine] [Sah. Jash] a liar, an adherent of a cursed belief, and should not be regarded [Sah] Ibn Hamdan al-Khusayb [Sixth].

Reference: Jame al-Rowaat Book 1
Hadith No: 4
Sayyid Ali al-Borujerdi - Tara'if al-Maqal
Volume: (1) - Page Number: (168)
873 - al-Husayn ibn Hammadān al-Junbalānī al-Hudayni, Abu Abdullah, narrated from him al-Tal'akkbari (he was not) was that was not was not that was not were is that is was are that are not is that is is was was was was are are are are there is is is not is was is was is not that are is is is is is is that is is knew that is not was is was knew (Baraghani) (he was not was was was that not not not not not is is is is is is not was is is not not not is is not is not is knew is not not is is not is not not is not is not knew knew knew is not is not not not not not is is is not is not is not is not not not knew not not not not not not not not is is is not is not is not knew knew is is is is is knew not not not not not not is is is is is is is is is is is not is is is knew is not is is not is not not not knew knew not not not is not not not knew knew knew is is is is is not not is is not not not not not is is is is is not is not is not is not not is is is is is is is not not is is not not is is is is is not not not is not is not not is not is is is is is is is is knew is is is not not is is is is knew not is is not knew not is is is not knew not is is not is not not not not is not knew not not not not not not not is is not not knew knew not is not not not not not is not is not is not not not not not is not is is is is knew knew not not is not not is not is not not not not not not not not is is is is is is is is is is not is not is is is not is knew is is is is is is is is is is is is not is is is is is not is not is not is not is not not is not not not not not is not not is is is not is is not is not not is not not is is not is is is is is is not not is is is not is not is is is is is not is not is knew so not is not not not is knew not not knew is not is is is not is not is not is not not is is is not is not is not is is is is is is is is is is is not is not not is not not is not is is not is not is is is is is is not is is is is is not is not is is is not is not is not is not is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is not is not is not is not no not is is not is is not not knew knew knew is is not not knew is knew not is not not not not is is not is not not not not is is is is is not not is is is is not not not is not is not is not is is ist is is is is is is is is is is not not knew is is is is not is not not is not is is not is not is not is not is not not is is is is not is not is is not is is not is is is is is is is not is is is is is not not is not is is is is not not is is is is is is is is is is not not not is not not is not is not is is is not knew is not not is not not is is is is not not is is is is is not is is is is not not is is not not is is is is is is is is not is not not is not is not is is is is is is is is knew not is not is not not not not not is is is is is is is is is not not not not not not not not is is is is not not not is not not not is is is is is not is not is not not is not not not not is is is is is not not is is is is knew is is is is is not is is not is is not not is not is is not is is not is is is is is is is is knew is is is is is is is is is is not not is is is is is is is is not is is is is not is is is is is is is is is not not is not is not is not is not is not is is is is is not not is not is is not is is not is not is is not is not is is is is is is not is is is is not not is is knew is is is not is not not not not not is not is not is is is not is is is is is is is not not is is is is is is is is is is is is is is not is is not is is is not is not not is not knew is not is is is not is is is is is is is is is is is not not is is is is is is is is is is is is is not not not is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is not is is is not is is is is is is not is not is not is not not is is is not is is is not is is is is is is not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not knew not not is is is is is not is is is is is not not is is is is is is is is is not not is is is not is is is not is not not is is not is not not is not not is not is is is is is is is not not not not not is not knew knew knew is is is is is is is is is not not not not is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is not is not is is is not is not not not not is is is is is is is is is is is is knew knew not not is is is is is not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not not is not is is is not is is is not not not not not not not not is is is is is is is is is is is is is is is

Reference: Taraaif al-Maqaal Book 1